HomeThe Hidden Harm of the Diagnosis of personality disorder report

The Hidden Harm of the Diagnosis of personality disorder report

For over 35 years, across our projects and services, we have listened to people’s experiences of the mental health system. Time and time again, we’ve heard experiences where the mental health system causes people more harm than help, and stories of people’s human rights not being upheld.

This is why we have made it an organisational mission to advocate for, and apply to our own services and influencing work, a holistic and social justice approach to mental health.

In this report we focus on the stories of the diagnosis of personality disorder.

Our findings

  1. Health is compromised
    Receiving the diagnosis of personality disorder had significant implication for the quality of care people received, and increased people’s chances of being excluded from lifesaving care and support. In the mental health system, it is women that are predominantly impacted by the diagnosis as they account for 75% of the people that get given it.
  2. Trauma experiences are ignored
    Despite the strong emphasis on trauma-informed care from Welsh Government, participants’ accounts revealed a widespread failure to acknowledge, assess, or understand individual trauma histories as part of routine clinical practice. When experiences were shared, they were often belittled or ignored.
  3. The diagnosis of personality disorder can challenge human rights
    Our findings give cause for concern that this diagnosis goes against international human rights law, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) and the Welsh Government guidance on reducing restrictive practices. In doing so, the diagnosis discriminates against a person’s rights to free and informed consent, privacy, liberty and security, personal integrity, and access to justice.

Content information: this report contains references to experiences relating to suicide and suicidal ideation, self harm, mental distress, and abuse. 

This report shines a necessary light on the diagnosis of ‘personality disorder’. As the findings make starkly clear, this label often serves not as a gateway to support, but as a barrier to compassion. — Alexis Quinn Survivor, psychotherapist, author and manager of the Restraint Reduction Network